PLL fans, I need your input! I finished PLL #6: Killer, within 24 hours of getting it but I still have some lingering questions!
HOW IS ALI NOT DEAD? Did she have a twin sister? Did they never confirm that it was really her body? Is Jenna not really blind? What is really wrong with Jason? And if Ali wasn’t dead this whole time and has been acting as A, why did she wait a few years to start torturing her old friends? Discuss!
July 16, 2009 at 1:07 PM
omg i know! i think ali really had to pose being dead BECAUSE of jason and wilden saying something.
but the twin idea makes sense because if you rememeber ian and spencer say they saw ali talking to a blond person.
about jason…I HAVE NO IDEA!i think hes being stalked/blackmailed beacuse he is all nice and normal and then he freaks out.
ali has NOT been acting like A.or else she would of said hey guys and not been clueless.
i cant believe we have to wait til heartless!
July 18, 2009 at 3:23 PM
I don’t want to wait so long for a new book! I wish Heartless was out already.
So, I am not sure if that was Ali, or if it was a twin. Part of me wonders how they would be able to hide a twin, and the girls were in the DiLaurentis house so often that it would be almost impossible for them not to know. Maybe Wilden and Jason were hiding Ali somewhere, and she has amnesia? I don’t know whose body they found in the hole then, though. The book also mentioned that they were still waiting for DNA results to come in, so it was never actually proven to be Ali’s body.
I also want to know what the deal is with the picture of Ali and Jenna and the mysterious blonde girl. Who was it? If it was Naomi, why wasn’t Riley in the picture? Strange, strange, strange.
July 20, 2009 at 11:05 AM
okay i dont think ali has a twin but remember in the fourh book mona said she saw someone there? well what if mona was the blond Ian saw? i dont know who would be dead in the whole in ali’s back yard but the second blond could have been mona… and if ali had a twin then what happened to her? and jason had to be atleast 5 years old when ali and her “twin” were born so he would remember it and how could ali’s parents give away only one twim if they didnt want her? thats so horrible
July 26, 2009 at 2:19 PM
I dont think that Ali had a twin sister but the whole woods thing was weird…and they did say they were waiting for DNA results so maybe it was Ali in the woods with amnesia and she just went missing but was never really dead…but i dont think that Ali was a
I also dont think that Jenna is blind and that she has been hiding it for a secret reason that we do not know and i beleive that jason is acting sketchy because maybe Ali really is back and she was never dead but he did have something to do with her disapperance.
July 28, 2009 at 5:15 PM
ugh i neeeeed this next book.
August 1, 2009 at 5:29 AM
WOW
So what’s the deal with Wilden & Jason? What exactly did they do? Abuse Ali? How did Aria find Ali?
August 10, 2009 at 11:13 AM
I think Ali had a twin who was insane or something like that, and for that reason was kept locked up at Radley. On one of here visits home (the night of Ali’s murder) she escaped the house and either a) tried to kill Ali, b) Jason and wilden tried to kill her, c) She fell into the hole in her parent’s backyard, or d) Ali accidently killed her and posed as here twin to make it look like she (Ali) had died.
August 18, 2009 at 8:19 PM
Ali might have a twin. Maybe Mr and Mrs Dilaurentis picked ali instead of her twin and she found out ? Her twin might have gone crazy after that and met Ali outside Spencer’s barn. She could’ve pushed Ali into the hole cos’ she was angry at her.
August 24, 2009 at 10:15 PM
maybe the blonde was jason melissa mona jenna it couldve be anyone with blonde hair
September 26, 2009 at 8:58 PM
ABOUT ALI HAVING A TWIN!!!::: spoiler if you havent read up to #6
i think that for sure ali has a twin. i think her twin was crazy. i mean she had to have a twin bc if you remember in like the flashbacks that the girls used to have one was at alis house and they saw her in her room snickering over a journal and then mrs dilaurents came in and was like ali i need to talk to you…and so the girls went onto the porch and they sat. when they saw ali came down with them and was like hey guys and she was wearing diff clothes and seemed clueless abt it. also when they figured out that ali didnt draw the frog on her flag even though she said she had th day the girls had gone to her house to try to steal the flag. but they realize there is no frog on it, prob bc ali drew stuff but the twin went outside and when the girls asked what she had drawen she forgot. ahhh she for sureeee has a twin i would bet on it!!!!!!!!!! I CANT WAIT TIL HEARTLESSSSSS
September 26, 2009 at 9:01 PM
oo and if you remeber at the end of KILLER it says that all the girls recognized who it was but the girl looked clueless…it must be bc it is the twin or ali with amnesia. but for sure one of them had to die. i think they got sick of having both of them and knew one of then had to die. i guess well find out who it was in the hole in heartlesssssssssss
xoxo
December 11, 2009 at 9:39 PM
okay i def think ali has a twin because in one of the books in a flashback it said the girls were at alis house and her mom said ali i need to talk to to u and in like 5 seconds she came back in a totally different outfit acting all clueless.
December 11, 2009 at 10:19 PM
very good point! i wonder why they would pretend the twins were only one person though?
December 25, 2009 at 11:09 PM
okay so i thikn that ali had a twin, and the twin was crazy and and lived at radley, and went home to viset her family some times, but i was reading the first 75 pages that are posted, and there where like pills percribed for ali out on the trash and what they where for it was scratched out, so thats kinda sketch and there has to be somthing leading up to that or else it probably wouldnt be montioned. aand there has to be something up with wilden and jason, ike why does jason freak oout so easily, and why are the cops not beliving them, and how did aria find that ring in the woods if the cops didnt, so the police must have not really been searching the woods,a dn also where would ali be living before if she was alvie, maybe she was squatting at her old house, because it said that one of the girls had seen a blond flash of hair in mayas house even thouhg the familys black, who could that be, also there all seeing blond flashes of hair everywhere. or maybe all of the four girls really are crazy.im so confused i want to read all of heartless, but here first 75 pgs are at http://browseinside.harperteen.com/index.aspx?isbn13=9780061566141
if anyone didnt know.
December 29, 2009 at 1:31 PM
ali obviously hhad a twin or a secret sister because in the fourth book when hanna is in a coma she goes back to the memory of ali sitting on her bed wearing a halter top laughing at the diary, then her mom needs to talk to her and she comes back wearing an abercrombie tee. also emily overhears jason arguing with someone who sounded like ali and the girl said im not hurting anyone and jason said his family is too messed up and they keep seeing someone who looks like ali even after monas death
December 29, 2009 at 10:21 PM
if you go on amazon.com you can read the first chapter of heartless.
January 3, 2010 at 12:44 AM
I really dont know what to think maybe ali did have a sister because jenna said ali had sibling issues and maybe those issues included her twin sister, but maybe we are wrong and ali has amnesia and she doesn’t recognize them or may be she is a ghost(kidding) I think that the one that was in the hole was the twin and the real ali survived and got amnesia or maybe she’s calling for help but at the same time she is protecting them i don’t know.
January 5, 2010 at 1:40 AM
Okay I love this series and all, but come the fuck on. Don’t you think she’s dragging it on a little too far? I mean, the 6th book is out and we still don’t know anything about anything. And there’s still 2+ books coming out, so you know you’re not going to know anything after Heartless, or probably not after Wanted either. I mean its just kinda ridiculous, its frustrating and its stupid to wait for a book that’s just going to put you even further away from figuring anything out. END THE FUCKING SERIES ALREADY! Or at LEAST give us some DAMN ANSWERS. Shit.
January 27, 2010 at 10:34 PM
I read heartless and I’m starting to believe that Ali has a twin Sister. I do because of Jason having “sibling” problems — maybe because there were two Ali’s and he couldn’t handle it. And, I caught onto what Mr. Hastings said in the parking lot about, “I didn’t know until after about the kids…”? So, Jason couldn’t be his son so maybe Ali had a twin Sister and that’s who they found in the hole. I’m very confused and at first I thought Spencer & Melissa or Mona killed her but, then I realized that the twin theory works or that Mona and her were secretly friends with Ali. Maybe ALi is the new A or her twin sister Is?
March 10, 2010 at 6:34 PM
I too am devouring these books! Many of my friends are hooked on them too. :)
In Killer we found out Jason DiLaurentis and Wilden were longtime friends and had planned to kill Alison DiLaurentis together. At the end of the book when Spencer, Emily, Aria and Hanna escape the fire and find a girl with a black hoodie it also says:
“…It was Ali.”
Nobody can tell! That’s the genius in Sarah Shepards’ writing! :D